|
There is much debate
around e-books and their potential
uptake, which to date has been slow.
There are a number of reasons for this,
including concern among publishers about
loss of revenue (if print sales go down)
and
also nervousness about providing course
texts online as there is a lack of
evidence regarding demand.
Publishers, librarians
and aggregators are unsure about what
are the most realistic and sustainable
pricing and licensing models for
providing students with online access to
course texts.
A potential disadvantage
often cited is that people will not read
books online. However, a Joint
Information Systems Committee (JISC)
study of e-book usage in the UK has
revealed
“62% of students reported
that they read online whilst only 6%
said they print to read. Students say
the main attraction is that e-books are
more accessible than print books,
meaning that users can get at them
wherever they are and at whatever time
they like.”
|
|
Some of the more obvious
advantages of e-books in the academic
environment are speed of supply and 24/7
access, wherever you happen to be.
Part-time and distance learners would
particularly benefit from the latter
point. Multiple simultaneous
access to texts is another clear
advantage. Other advantages are
automatic return, so books are never
overdue and no damaged or lost books. |

|
|
Up to a year ago many
suppliers were insisting on selling
collections of e-books, usually by
subject, rather than individual titles.
Many were concentrating on supporting
research rather than undergraduate
courses. Many required a hefty platform
fee before a single e-title was
purchased. Few were attempting to
incorporate the advantages of the print
model in a digital environment. With
the print model, a library can order a
single copy of a title, or as many
copies as they like.
|
|
 |
Rather than waiting for
the market to develop, DCU library
decided to investigate at first hand the
challenges of integrating e-books into
the academic environment. With this in
mind, we initiated an e-books pilot in
June this year. |
|
The purpose of the pilot
is:
- to ascertain the
level of availability of core reading
material
for undergraduates.
- to increase accessibility of the core collection
- to enhance speed of supply of core
texts
- to test the benefits of e-books for
the user community
- to gain experience of the e-books
market |
|
While we already provide
access to thousands of e-books through
the
library website
many through the IReL initiative, these
are not focussed specifically on
undergraduate course needs. |
|
The bulk of our e-books
are now provided by three main
suppliers, each of which employs a
different purchasing model. One of the
more interesting models is Dawson’s,
which provides 400 credits (uses) for
each book per year. If the credits run
out before the end of the year, we can
either purchase a second copy, or allow
rentals for the duration of the year
until the 400 credits are reinstated.
|
|
The merit of this system
is that we are basing our purchasing
decisions on proven demand, not on
anticipated demand as in the print
environment. In the case of Dawson
e-books, we can provide unlimited
simultaneous access to each title – an
important consideration in relation to
core textbooks. |
 |
|
In addition to our three
main suppliers, we purchase e-books from
dozens of other suppliers – occasionally
we find the book we wish to purchase is
available free online! In the case
of all suppliers, we have opted for
ownership in perpetuity rather than the
subscription model. |
|
The pilot is concentrated
on the area of core textbooks for
undergraduates. For every multiple copy
order we receive, we substitute an
e-book for two print copies. As a
result of the pilot we currently have 80
e-books spread across all subject areas
which will shortly be available through
the catalogue. This number will of
course increase as the year progresses.
They can be accessed by clicking on the
e-books button
on the library catalogue
to view the full list,
or by searching the catalogue in the
usual way. The link will bring you
straight into the text of the e-book.
There is also the potential to
incorporate core e-texts in Moodle. |
|
The success of the pilot
will depend to a large degree on
promotion and training. Both library
and academic staff have a role to play
in ensuring that the level of awareness
is high. The pilot will be reviewed at
the end of the year and its success will
be measured in terms of usefulness to
students, cost and the administrative
impact on the library. We hope that
e-books will become an established part
of the DCU information environment.
|
|
For e-books to become established,
the industry needs to move towards
standardisation of platforms,
purchasing models and licensing
terms. However, in DCU we have at
least raised awareness of demand
with publishers. Many have changed
their position and are now
responding to the type of material
we require, in the way that we wish
to acquire it. |

|
|
The ‘hit rate’ of available titles
has also improved immeasurably over
the past year. We are finding
more and more text books available
electronically. |
|
Current thinking is that
e-books are about to take off – in the
way that e-journals did some years ago.
We hope that this is the case – and are
confident that as we in DCU have already
‘dipped our toe in the water’ we are
ready for take-off! |